Sheppard, the legendary public address announcer for the Yankees, died on that date, but Jeter had such a connection with him that he uses an audio recording of Sheppard every time he steps to the plate at the Stadium.

MORE: Memorable All-Star Game moments

On Tuesday night, Jeter stepped into the batter’s box at Minnesota’s Target Field to lead off the bottom of the first inning for the American League All-Star team, and Sheppard’s voice was there to greet him.

After tipping his cap to the fans, Jeter stepped in and laced an opposite-field double off Adam Wainwright, but not before a fan scremed “OVERRATED” to the 14-time All-Star.

Jeter scored on a triple by the very next hitter, Mike Trout.