Now, it seems the public may need to wait even longer.

Liberty “Libby” German, 14, and Abigail Williams, 13, were found dead on February 14, 2017, a day after the girls went exploring on the Monon High Bridge Trail in Delphi, Indiana.

After five years, police finally arrested Richard Allen, 50, as a suspect in the murder and announced his arrest on October 31. Throughout the investigation, police have kept case details close to the vest, not revealing how the girls were killed and many other details for fear of hindering the investigation. The public had little to go on—only a video with audio captured from German’s smartphone depicting a man walking toward the person taking the video saying the words: “Guys, down the hill.”

Despite the arrest and the case’s national attention, the public still doesn’t have the answers it wants. Allen’s probable cause affidavit, which is likely to reveal information on why the police deem him a suspect, was sealed.

Allen, who has pled not guilty to the murder charges, wore a bullet-proof vest over his jumpsuit while attending the hearing.

Many Indiana media outlets filed a request to unseal the court records for public transparency. A judge heard the arguments Tuesday and announced she would announce her decision at a later date.

After the hearing, Fox News reporter Max Lewis tweeted that the prosecutor in the case filed a motion for a gag order to prevent anyone involved from discussing the case details. In another tweet, Lewis explained that the prosecutor said the sealed document was because police believed another person was involved in the case, a shocking new element to the investigation.

The announcement was a surprise to defense attorney Andrew Baldwin as well. According to Baldwin, the sealed probable cause affidavit doesn’t mention another person involved in the case.

Prosecutors continue fighting to keep the case sealed, but according to tweets from Lewis, the defense wants the probable cause affidavit made public because they believe the state doesn’t have enough evidence against Allen.

Bob Segall, an investigative reporter for local news station WTHR, tweeted the defense team believes Allen didn’t murder the girls.

“Andrew Baldwin, defense attorney for Richard Allen, says ‘our client is the wrong guy,’” Segall tweeted. “He says the sealed probable cause affidavit is ‘flimsy.’ ‘You expect more than what I saw,’ he said.”

Update 11/22/22 3:52 p.m. ET: This article was updated with more information.