As reported by Snopes, Jesse Durfee shared the original video to his YouTube channel ThriftSchool, where he often shares tips and vlogs on reselling thrift-store finds.

In the video shared in 2020, Durfee is discussing CDs in the thrift store when he shows a “Gorasul: The Legacy of the Dragon” game to the camera. At 2:06, a smiling lady appears in the reflection of the case, but disappears when he flips it over.

After viewers began noticing the moment, it became a point of discussion, with many deciding it had to be a ghost spotting.

“I was creeped out of course when I was shown the image of the smiling lady. I had no clue she was even in the video until someone mentioned it in my YouTube comments,” Durfee told Newsweek.

“It’s as if she’s smiling too. spirits can be attached to items. Maybe that was her game and she loved it a lot,” speculated one user.

A year later and the video appeared in popular Youtuber Nuke’s Top 5 video titled “Top 10 SCARY Ghost Videos To Give You Da’ BUBBLEGUTS.” The video gained over 1.4 million views and was subsequently shared across social media channels.

“It seems that Jesse caught something unexpected. Something downright creepy,” said Nuke.

Now, one YouTube user has managed to solve it all, and the truth isn’t half as compelling as the speculation.

YouTube user SannaKD commented noted that there actually exists a poster behind Durfee, which was reflected when the CD was held at a slight angle towards it. As pointed out by SannaKD, the bottom of the poster can be seen for a split second when he flipped the camera around.

“When he shows the front of the CD, he’s holding the CD angled slightly to the right and leaning back, which means the reflection on the CD would be above and to the side of the shelf behind him. But when he shows the back of it, the CD is more parallel with the shelf itself and leaning back, meaning that the reflection would be just above the shelf behind him. If you look at around 2:28 (when he just turns around) you can see the bottom of a picture hanging on the wall behind and above the shelf that would match with the ‘smiling ghost woman,’” he wrote.

For those needing more proof than just the bottom of the poster, SannaKD also pointed viewers towards a recent video on Dunfree’s channel inside a Goodwill, where the full poster can be clearly seen at the 4:43 mark.

But even Durfee’s not completely sure of it all. “I still have no clue if the poster is the actual culprit,” he said. “A few comments pointed out that a poster looks like the lady in the reflection, but that poster was at a completely different Goodwill, so it may not actually be the answer. I plan on going back to the original Goodwill to see if there is the same poster on the wall.”

Likely, though the video showing the poster in all its glory may have been shot in a different Goodwill, most stores tend to use the same stock images and posters across their chains.

The mystery was fun while it lasted but there’s still a plethora of scary videos on Youtube to keep you going—2006’s “Relaxing Car Drive” video, anyone?

Update 8/06/21, 11:48 a.m. ET: This article has been updated to include comments from Jesse Durfee.